Principles
The diagnosis of a genetic disease requires a systematic
approach that takes clinical and genetic considerations
into account. Whereas clinical medicine tends to classify
diseases according to organ system, age of onset,
gender, or primary method of detection (radiology,
imaging techniques), medical genetics, like pathology,
is oriented towards the basic cause or lesion, in
this case the gene or genes affected by a relevant
genetic change. Genetic diagnosis is based on an interdisciplinary
analysis of all clinical and laboratory data from
a genetic perspective.
- Genetic diagnosis, a multistep procedure
The phenotype, which is the clinical manifestations
including individual and family history in medical
terms, is the starting point. The first decision
the medical geneticist must make is whether a pattern
of manifestations can be recognized. Tools that
can assist in this decision include training and
personal experience; appropriate textbooks and other
literature; and online search systems such as OMIM,
MEDLINE, PubMed, POSSUM, London Dysmorphology Data
Base for congenital malformations, and cytogenetic
databases. If a disease pattern can be recognized,
the next decision concerns the category of disease.
Although difficult to establish in practice, the
disease category is important for the next steps
to be taken. For this purpose, the McKusick catalog
of human genes and diseases, Mendelian Inheritance
in Man (MIM) and its online version (OMIM) are indispensable.
The possibility of genetic heterogeneity must be
considered at this stage. The term genetic heterogeneity
refers to a phenotype (disease) that has different
causes. A particular phenotype may be caused by
mutations at different loci (locus heterogeneity)
or by different mutant alleles at the same locus
(allele heterogeneity). All genetic diagnostic procedures
should be preceded by genetic counseling, which
properly includes obtaining the (informed) consent
of the persons involved.
- Genotype analysis by PCR typing of a polymorphic
restriction site
Genotype analysis by PCR typing of a polymorphic
restriction site is preferred to the more laborious
Southern blot hybridization (see p. 62). (Figure
adapted from Strachan and Read, 1999).
- Protein truncation test (PTT)
This is a test for frameshift, splice, or nonsense
mutations that leads to a truncated protein due
to an early stop codon created downstream of the
mutation. The truncated protein is detected in an
assay based on an in-vitro translation system. The
translation will be interrupted at a premature stop
codon resulting from the mutation. The size of the
newly translated protein is determined by gel electrophoresis.
PTT detects the approximate location of the mutation
as reflected by the size of the mutant protein.
PTT is useful in studying genes with frequent nonsense
mutations, such as the APC, BRCA1, and BRCA2 genes.
However, it cannot be applied for genes with frequent
missense mutations. The figure shown here is highly
schematic. (Adapted from Strachan and Read, 1999;
and Beaudet, 1998).
- References
Aase, J.M.: Diagnostic Dysmorphology. Plenum
Medical Book Company, New York, 1990.
Beaudet, A.L.: Genetics and disease, pp. 365–
395. In: Fauci, A.S., et al., eds., Harrison’s
Principles of Internal Medicine. 14th ed.
McGraw-Hill, New York, 1998.
Jones, K.L.: Smith’s Recognizable Patterns
of
Human Malformation. 5th ed. W.B.
Saunders, Philadelphia, 1997.
McKusick, V.A.: Mendelian Inheritance in Man.
A Catalog of Human Genes and Genetic Disorders.
12th ed. Johns Hopkins University
Press, Baltimore, 1998.
Strachan, T., Read, A.P.: Human Molecular
Genetics. 2nd ed. Bios Scientific Publishers,
Oxford, 1999.
van der Luijit, R., et al.: Rapid detection of translation
terminating mutations at the adenomatous
polyposis (APC) gene by direct protein
truncation test. Genomics 20:1–4,
1994.
Detection of Mutations without Sequencing
In addition to the detection of mutations by different
DNA fragments in Southern blots (p. 62), there are methods
based on differences in the hybridization of mutated
and normal segments of DNA. Incomplete hybridization
is determined by using short segments of singlestranded
DNA (oligonucleotides) with a sequence complementary
to the investigated region (see A). Other methods are
based on demonstrating incomplete hybridization with
mRNA (see B) or on the fact that a hybridized segment
of normal and mutant DNA is less stable than normal
DNA.
- Detection of a point mutation by oligonucleotides
Short segments of DNA (oligonucleotides) are used
to determine whether there is a mutation in a segment
of DNA (1, normal DNA; 2, mutation from G to A).
An oligonucleotide is a synthetically produced DNA
segment about 20 nucleotides long; its sequence
is complementary to a corresponding segment of the
investigated gene. It hybridizes completely with
its complementary segment (3). If a mutation, here
from G to A (1), is located in this region, hybridization
will not be perfect at this site (mismatch) (4).
On the other hand, an oligonucleotide that is complementary
to the DNA segment with the mutation will hybridize
completely (allele-specific oligonucleotide, ASO)
(5). This hybridizes incompletely with the normal
DNA (6). By parallel use of both nucleotides, mutant
and nonmutant DNA can be differentiated. The test
results (7) show the hybridization of mutated DNA
and of control DNA with the allele-specific oligonucleotides
(ASO 1 for the control, ASO 2 for the mutation).
Hybridization is indicated by a signal (dot-blot
analysis).
- Demonstration of a point mutation by
ribonuclease A cleavage
The basis for this method is that a normal DNA strand
hybridizes completely with mRNA from that region.
Completely hybridized DNA and mRNA are protected
from the effects of the RNA-splitting enzyme ribonuclease
A (ribonuclease protection assay). Hybridization
is incomplete in the area of a mutation. In this
region, mRNA will be cleaved by ribonuclease A (RNAase
A). This can be demonstrated by Southern blot. There
will be two fragments formed that together correspond
to the size of the completely hybridized fragment
(600 base pairs (bp), versus 400 and 200 bp).
- Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis
This method exploits differences in the stability
of DNA segments with and without mutation. While
double-stranded DNA of a control person is completely
complementary (homoduplex), a mutation leads to
a mismatch at the site of mutation (heteroduplex).
This DNA is less stable than completely complementary
DNA strands (it has a lower melting point). If normal
DNA (control) and DNAwith the mutation are placed
in a gel with an increasing concentration gradient
of formamide (denaturing gradient gel), the mutant
and normal DNA can subsequently be differentiated
in a Southern blot. The normal DNA remains stable
to higher concentrations of formamide and migrates
farther than mutant DNA, which dissociates earlier
and therefore does not migrate as far.
- References
Caskey, C.T.: Disease diagnosis by recombinant
DNA methods. Science 236:1223–1229,
1987.
Dean, M.: Resolving DNA mutations. Nature
Genet. 9:103–104, 1995.
Mashal, R.D., Koontz, J., Sklar, J.: Detection of
mutations by cleavage of DNA heteroduplexes
with bacteriophage resolvases. Nature
Genet. 9:177–183, 1995.
|